
Part 1: Does My Doubt Mean I’m Falling Away?
I sat with my doubt long enough to see it was fear.*
“My relationship with God is terrible. It’s worse than it ever has been. I remember sweet times just two years ago when I felt close to the Lord; I listened, and I felt his peace. Now all of that is gone.”
Years ago, this statement by Mark would have made me shift in my seat or doubt how to help. In my earliest counseling days, I didn’t know what to do and was quiet. As I was first learning how to approach someone like Mark, I talked too much. How amazing it is for me to have all the right answers!
That reality was quickly quashed when I saw people facing real suffering. I mean, even if I had some correct ideas about what was needed and where we would go, I came across sometimes as a bit of a twit when I rushed to answers.
So, I sat.
His discomfort. My discomfort.
I listened. I asked questions. I listened some more.
Mark continued, “I read passages that used to seem so clear. I can’t read anything bad with a warning about lacking faith or ‘I never knew you’ [Matthew 7:23], or I just spiral. I feel awful. But I can’t read anything good, either, because as soon as I read the old comforts of Psalm 23, I feel, ‘That’s not for you, Mark, that’s for those who trust in God.’”
I gained a better understanding of what Mark was trying to say, including his history, emotions, beliefs about what was happening, and behaviors.
“I feel like I am of two minds,” Mark wrestled. “Leaders in my church know me well. They know I’m anxious and encourage me, but what if they don’t know the real me, you know? I feel constant doubt. No sooner do I say, “I believe!” than my thoughts say I don’t. I don’t even feel like going to church, reading Scripture, or praying.”
Mark sighed, “Isn’t that proof right there? Doesn’t that mean I’m falling away?”
Naming the Noise: What Doubt Actually Is
In faith circles, doubt is often seen as an enemy of faith, and no matter what is said from the pulpit about the normalcy of doubt and the importance of working through it, the surrounding culture is a better predictor of what’s learned than any single words from a platform.
How do you experience doubt? What is it like in your community?
Merriam-Webster defines doubt thus: “to call into question the truth of: to be uncertain or in doubt about.” It can also be a lack of confidence.
Doubt is common; two-thirds of Christians face doubts about their faith. Frankly, it’s hard for me to believe this number isn’t 100% at some point, but it’s not.
My first supervisor in my clinical training shocked me when I asked if he ever doubted his faith. He said plainly, “No.”
Jaw drop. A therapist. Trained at the doctoral level. One who sees all the pain and suffering in the world every day in his office. He never doubted his faith in Christ?!
I knew him well enough to trust that he was being honest, and he was emotionally intelligent enough to know if he wasn’t. Wow. Praise God that some Christians really are this way. Not most.
Then take people like Mark, and yes, they are in a minority of those who have OCD (2.3% lifetime prevalence), but if you include people with anxiety disorders (30% +, including OCD) or just general doubt, now the numbers stack up to a majority.
Quick Definitions
Here are some key definitions to help understand some differences:
- Uncertainty—inability to know completely or have confidence
- Doubt—torn between two or more options without committing
- Unbelief—committing to not believe or absence of belief
- Disbelief—entrenched refusal to believe
Doubt to Disbelief—Not the Same
I included the four distinctions above because sometimes we assume we’re talking about the same thing. In therapy, that’s part of what we do: identify what we’re really talking about in the first place.
So doubt calls something into question, leaving its truth uncertain. Uncertainty itself is slightly different. I’m uncertain where I will attend church in 10 years, or whether I will live, or who my friends will be. I’m not currently calling it into question, so I’m not doubting. Sometimes I doubt whether God actually parted the Red Sea. I choose to believe by faith that He did.
While Mark definitely struggled with moments of doubt, I would say most of his struggles were with uncertainty. He didn’t feel certain. However, when both were present, we were able to approach strategically and identify reasonable ways forward. I taught him to ask one question of a faith leader, accept the answer, and move forward.
With Mark, to the extent that his OCD needed to be addressed, we did that. To the extent that spiritual practices and questions needed support, I encouraged him to do that through the appropriate channels. This is part of the holistic mind, body, and spirit care that’s essential to overall well-being.
Go back to my first quote above: I sat with my doubt long enough to see it was fear. For those I work with, doubt is often more about fear than anything else. It’s like when my writing coach told me writer’s block is just fear. I think she’s correct. Doubt highlights a moment of being stuck between options. What lives in this space more than fear?
Next part: What Scripture and the testimony of the saints actually say about doubt and why Jesus didn’t rebuke John the Baptist’s questions. Subscribe to stay in the loop!
Notes:
*Someone once said, “I sat with my anger long enough until she told me her real name was grief” (Anonymous, often attributed to C.S. Lewis). I took this phrase and coined my own version of it.
Disclaimer: The examples used involve composites of very real symptoms and suffering, despair, and hope. The information doesn’t identify any specific individual. This is provided only for educational purposes—not as a substitute for professional diagnosis or treatment. Read full Disclaimers & Disclosures here.








Leave a Reply